I love exploring good pizza joints in Colorado Springs. This city has some amazing options for pizza lovers like me. From traditional New York-style slices to unique gourmet pies, there’s something to satisfy every craving.
I’ve sampled countless pizzas across Colorado Springs to bring you my top 5 picks for the best pizza restaurants in the city. These spots stand out for their quality ingredients, perfect crusts, and mouthwatering flavor combinations. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these pizza joints are worth checking out.
1) Il Vicino
Their Neapolitan-style pizzas are a cut above the rest.
Il Vicino is a beloved dining spot in Colorado Springs, known for its artisan wood-fired pizzas and inviting atmosphere. Their focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients and traditional Italian techniques makes every bite memorable.
Rating: 4.5 (1,800 reviews)
Location: 11 S Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
Contact: (719) 475-9224
2) Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria
Bambino’s Urban Pizzeria is a standout pizza joint in Colorado Springs. I love their commitment to using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients.
Their Neapolitan-style pizzas are a cut above the rest.
The dough at Bambino’s is made from Italian-milled flour and hand-stretched to perfection. They top it with homemade mozzarella and fresh produce from nearby farms. It’s clear they take pride in their craft.
What sets Bambino’s apart is their fast-fired cooking method. They can deliver a piping hot, delicious pizza in just 10 minutes.
It’s the perfect spot for a quick lunch or dinner without sacrificing quality.
Rating: 4.6 (2000 reviews)
Location: 36 E Bijou St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903
Contact: (719) 630-8121
Website: Visit Website
3) Leon Gessi New York Pizza
Leon Gessi New York Pizza offers authentic New York-style pies that transport me straight to the Big Apple with every bite.
The crust is thin and crispy, just like you’d expect from a NY slice. They have generous toppings and perfectly melted cheese. Their sauce has a great balance of tangy and sweet flavors.
Leon Gessi’s has been serving the community for years, and it shows in their consistently high quality. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, perfect for a family dinner or a quick lunch.
They offer unique combinations that go beyond the usual pepperoni and cheese. The staff is friendly and efficient, ensuring a pleasant dining experience.
Rating: 4.6 (2800 reviews)
Location: 1806 Palmer Park Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80909
Contact: (719) 635-1542
Website: Visit Website
4) Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana
Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana brings authentic Neapolitan pizza to the city. They use traditional methods passed down through generations.
The pizzeria imports its wood-fired oven straight from Naples. This Acunto oven is the heart of their kitchen, reaching temperatures of 1000 degrees. It allows them to create pizzas with perfect crusts in just minutes.
Basil & Barley offers classic Neapolitan pizzas like Margherita and Marinara. They also have unique options, including pizzas with organic charcoal crust and homemade gluten-free options.
Beyond pizza, you can try their fried starters, salads, wings, and homemade desserts.
The restaurant provides a full dining experience with table service. They aim to recreate the welcoming atmosphere of Naples.
With their focus on both great pizza and top-notch service, it’s a standout choice for pizza in Colorado Springs.
Rating: 4.4 (1300 reviews)
Location: 9278 Forrest Blfs Vw, Colorado Springs, CO 80920
Contact: (833) 692-2745
Website: Visit Website
5) Slice 420
Slice 420 is a standout pizza joint in Colorado Springs. Their commitment to quality ingredients and family-friendly atmosphere really impressive.
They serve up New York-style pizza that’s gotten a lot of praise from locals and food critics alike.
What makes Slice 420 special is the story behind it. The owners moved to Colorado to access alternative medicine for their daughter Sofia, who has epilepsy and cerebral palsy. They named the restaurant after her and use it to raise awareness about medical issues.
The menu at Slice 420 offers whole pies and pizza by the slice. They’ve expanded to a second location on the east side of town, making it easier for more people to enjoy their food. The new spot is bigger and even has a full bar.
Rating: 4.7 (3000 reviews)
Location: 2501 W Colorado Ave #108, Colorado Springs, CO 80904
Contact: (719) 368-6977
Website: Visit Website
Bonus) Walter’s303 Pizzeria & Publik House | Flying Horse
Walter’s303 Pizzeria & Publik House in Flying Horse offers a great dining experience. Their menu features tasty pizzas that keep customers coming back.
The restaurant has a welcoming atmosphere. Families and regulars alike feel at home here. The patio provides nice views, perfect for enjoying a meal outdoors.
Walter’s303 takes pride in their craft beer selection. With 20 rotating taps, beer enthusiasts can always find something new to try. The pizzeria also hosts special events like pint nights and exclusive tappings.
The owners, Debby and Dave, bring years of pizza-making experience. Their focus on family and local connections shines through in the restaurant’s friendly vibe.
Rating: 4.6 (1300 reviews)
Location: 2690 North Gate Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80921
Contact: (719) 487-3006
Website: Visit Website
Unique Ingredients at Colorado Springs Pizzerias
Colorado Springs pizza places use some cool ingredients to make their pies stand out.
Locally Sourced Produce
I’ve seen pizzerias in Colorado Springs using veggies from nearby farms. Places like Pizzeria Rustica get their greens and tomatoes from local growers. This means the toppings are super fresh.
Some spots even have their own gardens. They grow herbs like basil and oregano right on site. This adds a nice touch to their pizzas.
Artisanal Cheese Varieties
The cheese game in Colorado Springs pizza joints is strong. I’ve tried pies with fancy goat cheeses from local dairies. Some places even make their own mozzarella in-house.
There’s one spot that uses a smoked provolone that’s amazing. Another place tops their pizzas with blue cheese from a nearby creamery.
I’ve seen menus with options like aged parmesan and creamy burrata. These fancy cheeses really take the pizzas to the next level.
Some places even offer vegan cheese alternatives. This is great for people who can’t eat dairy but still want a cheesy pizza experience.
Ambiance and Dining Experience
Pizza restaurants in Colorado Springs offer varied atmospheres to suit different preferences. Some places focus on family fun, while others create intimate settings for date nights.
Family-Friendly Atmosphere
Many pizza spots in Colorado Springs welcome families with open arms. These restaurants often have bright, cheerful decor and plenty of space for large groups. Some feature game rooms or play areas to keep kids entertained.
The menus at family-friendly pizzerias usually include options that appeal to picky eaters. I’ve seen places offering build-your-own pizza bars where kids can choose their own toppings. This interactive experience adds to the fun dining atmosphere.
Noise levels tend to be higher at these restaurants, with a lively buzz of conversation and laughter. The staff is typically patient and accommodating to families with young children.
Cozy and Romantic Settings
For couples or adults seeking a quieter meal, Colorado Springs has pizza places with more intimate vibes. These restaurants often have dimmer lighting and cozy booth seating.
Some feature exposed brick walls or rustic wood decor for a warm ambiance.
I’ve noticed that these cozier spots tend to have more extensive wine lists and craft cocktail menus. They might offer gourmet pizza options with unique toppings or wood-fired ovens for an elevated dining experience.
The pace is usually slower in these settings, allowing for relaxed conversation over a shared pizza. Some places have outdoor patios with string lights, perfect for enjoying a slice on a cool Colorado evening.
Leave a Reply